Finding Neverland on Broadway is an absolute treasure. Everything from the story to the cast to the set to the costumes – we were both riveted. I laughed, I cried. Matthew Morrison is so delightful in the role originated by Johnny Depp in the film, a semi-fictionalized account of J.M. Barrie‘s creation of Peter Pan. At first I was taken back by his Scottish accent – he lays it on thick, but I got used to the fact that I wasn’t watching Mr. Schue from Glee – as did my love-struck tween.